business
Qz.com Ranks the Cheapest S&P 500 Index Funds for 2026

Quartz published a 2026 ranking of S&P 500 index funds sorted by what each charges investors to hold it, according to the outlet's report. The comparison is built around a single mechanism that determines most of the cost difference between otherwise similar products: the expense ratio.
What makes one S&P 500 index fund cheaper than another?
Every S&P 500 index fund is built to track the same 500-company benchmark, so the holdings look nearly identical across providers. The spread in annual cost between funds comes down almost entirely to the expense ratio each fund charges to cover management, administration, and trading costs tied to rebalancing the portfolio as the index changes. That fee is deducted from fund assets automatically; investors do not write a separate check for it, but it reduces the return they keep over time.
How is the expense ratio actually charged?
A fund's expense ratio is expressed as a percentage of assets under management and is subtracted gradually from the fund's net asset value, not billed as a lump sum. Two funds tracking the same index can report nearly identical pre-fee performance and still hand investors different results after fees, which is the comparison point Quartz's ranking is built around.
Does the cheapest fund always perform best?
Not necessarily, and fee alone does not settle the comparison. Tracking error — how closely a fund's actual return matches the index itself — and bid-ask spread for funds structured as ETFs can offset part or all of a fee advantage for a given investor, depending on trade size and timing. Quartz's framework ranks funds specifically by fee rather than by total realized return, a distinction worth noting before using the list to pick a single fund.
Where can investors see the 2026 rankings directly?
The full fund-by-fund list, including provider names, sits in Quartz's original article. HTT News previously examined how a sector-specific index product, the Vanguard Utilities Index Fund ETF Shares, discloses its own fee and tracking details — a useful template for reading any fund's prospectus line by line rather than relying on a headline fee figure alone.
What should an investor check before switching funds?
What to watch
- The expense ratio listed in the fund's prospectus, not a third-party summary.
- Whether the fund is a mutual fund share class or an ETF, since trading costs differ between the two structures.
- Minimum investment requirements, which can vary by share class at the same provider.
- Tax consequences of selling an existing position to move into a cheaper fund, which can erase a fee saving in a single year.
None of these factors are disclosed in the Quartz ranking itself, according to the available reporting, so investors comparing funds should read the underlying prospectus for the specific product under consideration before acting on a fee ranking alone.
mindfulAI Keyboard — An iPhone keyboard that rewrites a draft in a tone you pick. Four free AI actions a day.
Questions
What is an expense ratio?
It is the annual percentage of a fund's assets deducted to cover management and administrative costs, taken gradually from the fund's value rather than billed separately.
Does a lower fee guarantee a better return?
Not always; tracking error and, for ETFs, bid-ask spreads can offset part of a fee advantage depending on trade size and timing.