business
Advisors Explain the Apple Pie Approach to Tax Diversification

The "apple pie" approach to tax diversification, as laid out in a recent column from SiouxFalls.Business, treats a retiree's savings like slices of a pie — some taxed before retirement, some taxed after, and some never taxed at all — so that no single tax bracket or withdrawal rule controls the whole plan.
What Does the Apple Pie Metaphor Mean for Retirement Taxes?
The metaphor is a shorthand for an old financial-planning idea dressed in a kitchen analogy: instead of putting every dollar of retirement savings into one type of account, the money gets divided among accounts that are taxed differently depending on when the tax bill arrives. One slice gets taxed on the way in, another slice gets taxed on the way out, and a third slice is taxed continuously along the way. The point of the pie, according to the framing used in the SiouxFalls.Business column, is that a retiree who holds all three types has more control over taxable income in any given year than a retiree who holds just one.
Why Do Advisors Recommend Splitting Savings Across Tax Treatments?
Future tax rates are not fixed, and a retiree's income needs shift from year to year — a large medical bill, a part-time consulting job, or a spouse's Social Security claim can all change how much taxable income makes sense in a given year. Holding savings in only one tax treatment removes that flexibility.
Some taxed now, some taxed later, some never taxed again — that is the pie.
With three buckets available, a retiree can choose which account to draw from based on that year's tax situation rather than being forced into a single, fixed stream of taxable withdrawals.
What Are the Three Tax Buckets in the Apple Pie Model?
The model generally groups retirement savings into three categories, distinguished by when the IRS collects its share:
| Bucket | How contributions are taxed | How withdrawals are taxed |
|---|---|---|
| Tax-deferred (traditional 401(k), traditional IRA) | Typically reduces taxable income the year it's contributed | Taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn |
| Tax-free (Roth 401(k), Roth IRA) | Made with after-tax dollars | Qualified withdrawals are not taxed |
| Taxable (brokerage accounts) | Already taxed before it's invested | Gains and dividends can be taxed annually or at sale |
Three buckets, one goal: giving a retiree the option to pull income from whichever slice produces the smallest tax bill in a given year.
When Does Each Bucket Typically Get Taxed?
The timing of the tax bill is the entire reason the buckets are kept separate rather than combined into one account:
- While still working — contributions to tax-deferred accounts generally lower taxable income for that year; Roth contributions do not.
- In early retirement, before other income sources kick in — withdrawals from taxable brokerage accounts or Roth accounts can be used without raising ordinary taxable income, since Roth withdrawals aren't taxed and brokerage withdrawals may only trigger tax on the gain.
- Once mandatory withdrawals begin on tax-deferred accounts — those withdrawals count as ordinary taxable income whether or not the money is actually needed that year, which is one reason advisors suggest drawing down tax-deferred balances earlier rather than letting them grow untouched.
What Should Retirement Savers Watch For Next?
- Whether current individual income-tax rates remain in place or change once they are scheduled to expire, since that affects which bucket is cheapest to tap first.
- Whether a lower-income year — between a job ending and other income starting — makes converting part of a tax-deferred account to a Roth account cheaper than usual.
- Whether mandatory withdrawal rules on tax-deferred accounts are adjusted again, as they have been in recent years.
- Whether an advisor recommends rebalancing the three buckets as health costs, Social Security timing, or part-time income shift a retiree's tax picture.
Tax diversification is a separate question from investment diversification — spreading holdings across sectors or asset classes, the way an investor might look at a utilities-sector index fund. A retiree can hold a well-diversified portfolio inside a single tax bucket, or a narrow portfolio spread across all three buckets; the apple pie framework addresses only the second question.
Questions
What is the apple pie approach to tax diversification?
It is a metaphor used in retirement planning that compares splitting savings across tax-deferred, tax-free, and taxable accounts to cutting a pie into slices, so taxes come due at different times instead of all at once.
What are the three tax buckets in retirement planning?
Tax-deferred accounts such as traditional 401(k)s and IRAs, tax-free accounts such as Roth 401(k)s and Roth IRAs, and taxable brokerage accounts, each taxed at a different point in time.