news

Newsweek Opinion Says Retirement Savers Need a Withdrawal Plan

News

· news, business

An older couple reviewing retirement account statements and a withdrawal schedule at a kitchen table with a laptop open.
Photo by Markus Winkler / Pexels · source

Saving enough to retire is not the same task as making that money last, according to an opinion piece published by Newsweek that argues the two halves of retirement planning are too often treated as one. The piece's own headline frames the problem plainly.

"Saving for Retirement Is Only Half the Job"

That framing puts a label on a tension financial planners have discussed for years: building a balance is a different skill set from drawing it down without running out, outliving it, or mistiming withdrawals against a falling market.

What Is the Other Half of Retirement Planning?

The accumulation phase — contributing to a 401(k), an IRA, or a taxable brokerage account over a working career — has a single, measurable goal: grow the balance. The decumulation phase, the stretch of years after the paychecks stop, asks a harder question: how much can be withdrawn each year without the money running dry before the person does. The Newsweek piece's title points directly at that gap, treating the drawdown problem as a distinct discipline rather than an afterthought to saving.

That distinction matters because the two phases call for different tools. A savings plan can tolerate volatility because there is time to recover. A withdrawal plan has to account for the order in which gains and losses arrive, since a downturn early in retirement can do more lasting damage than the same downturn years later, even if the average return over time is identical.

How Do Income-Focused Funds Fit Into a Withdrawal Plan?

One practical response to the drawdown question is shifting part of a portfolio toward funds built to generate steady income rather than pure growth. The Wealthy Will's coverage of the Vanguard Utilities Index Fund ETF (VPU) looks at one example of that category: a fund built around a sector known for regulated revenue and dividend payouts rather than rapid share-price growth. Utilities-focused funds are one of several income-oriented options retirees and pre-retirees weigh when trying to generate cash flow without selling growth holdings at an inopportune time.

The broader point carries past any single fund. A withdrawal plan generally has to decide which assets get sold first, which get held for later years, and how much of the portfolio should be producing income on a regular schedule versus appreciating untouched.

Why Does Financial Confidence Lag Behind Savings Habits?

Planning for the drawdown years also runs into a more basic obstacle: confidence in financial tools and metrics. The Wealthy Will's reporting on a San Francisco survey on credit score perception found a negative view of credit scores among respondents there, a reminder that comfort with core financial metrics is uneven even before retirement-specific questions — tax sequencing, required withdrawals, income layering — enter the picture. A saver who is uneasy about a credit score is unlikely to feel more settled drawing up a decade-long withdrawal schedule without guidance.

How Does a Retirement Income Plan Typically Unfold?

Planners commonly describe the shift from saving to spending as a sequence rather than a single event:

  • Years before retirement: contributions continue, and the portfolio mix starts shifting toward the allocation that will support withdrawals.
  • The transition year: paychecks stop, and the first withdrawal decisions — what to sell, what to hold — get made.
  • Early retirement: withdrawals begin in earnest, often alongside Social Security claiming decisions.
  • Later retirement: required distributions and tax rules take on more weight as the account ages.

The Newsweek piece's framing suggests that plan should be built before the transition year arrives, not improvised after it.

What Should Retirement Savers Watch For Next?

  • Whether a withdrawal order is specified — which accounts get tapped first and why.
  • Whether part of the portfolio is positioned for income, not just growth, heading into retirement.
  • Whether comfort with basic financial metrics, including credit and debt, has been addressed alongside investment choices.
  • Whether the plan accounts for a downturn in the first few retirement years, not just the long-run average return.

The underlying argument from the opinion piece is narrow but hard to dismiss: a savings number on a statement does not by itself answer the question of how that money gets spent.

Disclosure. This article may include affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Legal entity: Pinewood Creations LLC. Smorgi Apps appears only as an affiliate partner in house slots — not as publisher or owner. See our affiliate disclosure.

Sources

More from The Wealthy Will

Briefing

Top stories from the HTT News network by email. Free. No noise.

More from our network